to top

A Glittering Journey Across the Wall: A Review of Neil Gaiman’s ‘Stardust’

book review

Who hasn’t at one point or another looked up at the night sky and dreamed of plucking a star right out of its cosmic dwelling? In Neil Gaiman’s ‘Stardust’, that’s exactly what our hero, Tristran Thorn, sets out to do. I remember the first time I read ‘Stardust’, armed with my skepticism about the overuse of fairies and magic dust in fantasy. Boy, was I in for a sweet surprise.


‘Stardust’ is the tale of Tristran Thorn, a not-so-charming lad living in the Victorian-esque town of Wall. For the captivating, cold, and capricious Victoria Forester, Tristran promises to bring a fallen star they both see plummeting into the mystical land beyond the wall. Little does Tristran know, his seemingly chivalrous vow sends him on a magical roller coaster through a land filled with witches, unicorns, and air pirates (yes, you heard me, air pirates).

Notable Quotes:

  1. “A philosopher once asked, ‘Are we human because we gaze at the stars, or do we gaze at them because we are human?’ Pointless, really…’Do the stars gaze back?’ Now, that’s a question.”
  2. “He wondered how it could have taken him so long to realize he cared for her, and he told her so, and she called him an idiot, and he declared that it was the finest thing that ever a man had been called.”
  3. “She says nothing at all, but simply stares upward into the dark sky and watches, with sad eyes, the slow dance of the infinite stars.”


Ever wish you could ditch the rigidity of reality for a bit and dive headlong into a world replete with magic, beauty, and adventure? Then Neil Gaiman’s “Stardust” is just the rabbit hole for you. Our protagonist, Tristran, is a slightly daft yet endearing young man, the type you’d secretly cheer for, despite the absurdity of his quest. You see, in his world, and perhaps only in his world, capturing a star seems like a perfectly reasonable pursuit to win over a woman’s heart.

The book unfolds like a splendidly intricate tapestry woven with threads of whimsy, peril, and enchantment. Gaiman’s command of language is magnificent; it’s a delightful marriage of wit and poetry. There are sentences in there that’ll make you pause, re-read, and perhaps sigh a little at the sheer beauty of words.

Now, if we’re being brutally honest here, as enchanting as “Stardust” is, it’s not the intricate, multi-layered fare of, say, “American Gods” or “The Sandman.” It’s a simpler story, a little like a sweet melody played on an old, well-loved guitar. But that’s not a dig at “Stardust.” Far from it. This novel is a lovely homage to the fairy tales of yore and an escape into a realm where the supernatural isn’t so… well, supernatural. It’s the perfect book to tuck into on a day when you want to shed your grown-up skin and slip back into the wide-eyed wonder of your childhood days.

Neil Gaiman, that sly fox, can turn even the most clichéd fantasy concepts into something fresh and zesty. The man has a talent for writing stories that seem to dance around in your head, weaving together an enchanting spell. ‘Stardust’ is no exception. It’s a gorgeously written, witty, and sly novel that warms your heart and tickles your funny bone, all while keeping you on the edge of your seat.

In the very beginning, the plot seems innocent, like a nursery story your dear old grandmother might tell you. But Gaiman’s knack for the twisted and the uncanny quickly manifests, and before you know it, you’re riding a crazy, imaginative roller coaster.

Tristran is not your typical knight in shining armor. He’s clumsy, a bit clueless, and a hopeless romantic, and it’s hard not to adore him. His adventures are humorous and thrilling, but they’re also punctuated with moments of quiet beauty and profound wisdom.

But perhaps the real star of ‘Stardust’ (pardon the pun) is Gaiman’s writing. He mixes the whimsical and the macabre in a way only he can, sprinkling his trademark humor all over the story. It’s like reading a Grimms’ fairy tale on a sugar high.


So, how many stars for a book about a star? Well, given the charming plot, loveable characters, and Gaiman’s brilliant writing, I’d give it a solid 4 out of 5 stars. ‘Stardust’ is an imaginative, enchanting, and wickedly funny book that will whisk you off to a world of magic, love, and star-crossed destiny.

Author Bio

Neil Gaiman, born in Hampshire, UK, in 1960, has made a name for himself across various literary genres, from fantasy and science fiction to graphic novels. He is known for his celebrated works like ‘Coraline’, ‘American Gods’, ‘Good Omens’ (co-authored with Terry Pratchett), and ‘The Sandman’ series. He’s received numerous awards, including the Hugo, Nebula, and Bram Stoker awards. His unique blend of horror, fantasy, and humor has secured him a special place in the literary world.

On Screen Adaptation

Gaiman’s fantasy masterpiece ‘Stardust’ found its way to the silver screen in 2007, featuring a star-studded cast that includes Claire Danes, Charlie Cox, and Michelle Pfeiffer. The movie version deviates from the novel in certain aspects, but it still manages to capture the whimsical essence and delightful humor of Gaiman’s original tale. It’s worth a watch, but of course, it doesn’t hold a candle to the book. When does it ever, really?

Study Questions:

  1. How does Neil Gaiman utilize traditional fantasy and fairytale tropes in ‘Stardust’? How does he subvert or play with these tropes to create something unique?
  2. Examine the character of Tristran Thorn. In what ways does he embody the characteristics of a typical fantasy hero, and how does he differ from this archetype?
  3. ‘Stardust’ is a coming-of-age tale for Tristran. Discuss the moments in the story that contribute to his character growth.
  4. Discuss the theme of love and how it manifests in different forms in ‘Stardust’.
  5. How does Gaiman’s use of humor and wit contribute to the overall tone and enjoyment of the story?
  6. What is the significance of the wall in the story, both literally and metaphorically?

Frequently Asked Questions:

  1. Is ‘Stardust’ suitable for young readers?
    • ‘Stardust’ contains a few mature themes and instances of violence, but it is generally suitable for teenagers and above. As always, it’s best for parents or guardians to read the book first to determine its suitability for their young reader.
  2. Do I need to read any other Neil Gaiman books before ‘Stardust’?
    • No, ‘Stardust’ is a standalone novel and doesn’t require familiarity with Gaiman’s other works. However, if you enjoy ‘Stardust’, you’ll likely enjoy his other books as well.
  3. How is the book different from the movie?
    • While the movie adaptation of ‘Stardust’ captures much of the book’s charm and humor, there are some plot differences and character modifications. The book has more depth and complexity, offering a richer experience of the world Gaiman created.
  4. Does the book have a sequel?
    • No, ‘Stardust’ is a standalone novel. However, Neil Gaiman’s expansive bibliography offers many other captivating reads.
  5. Why is the book named ‘Stardust’?
    • The title ‘Stardust’ refers to the main plot of the book, where Tristran Thorn ventures into the magical realm beyond the wall to bring back a fallen star. It also holds symbolic value, representing dreams, magic, and the stuff that makes us who we are.

Leave a Comment