A freshly dog-eared review
Books Like Fourth Wing: 17 Dragon-Rider Romantasy Reads, Honestly Tiered
I want it on the record that I held out against Fourth Wing for eight months, and that I lost, badly, in a Hudson News at Denver International.
Everything about the marketing annoyed me. The sprayed edges. The phrase “dragon smut” doing numbers on every platform I opened. Fan edits for a fictional war college. I had been burned before by books the internet swore on, so I did the snob thing and decided I knew exactly what this one was without reading a page of it. A romance novel wearing fantasy armor. Next.
Then my connection got delayed three hours, I’d finished the novel in my bag (very literary, very acclaimed, reading it felt like chewing a placemat), and the airport store offered me two options: Rebecca Yarros or a business book about morning routines. I read the parapet chapter standing up at the gate. You know the one. First day of dragon college, cross a knife-edge of stone in the rain or die, and the book kills a named character before you’ve finished your coffee. I read the Threshing somewhere over Nebraska. I finished at 1:40 in the morning in a hotel with terrible wifi, doing math on whether any bookstore in the city could put Iron Flame in my hands by nine.
Here’s the confession part. A friend recommended Fourth Wing to me back in January and I sent her something snide about TikTok deciding what we read now. In August I texted her four words: okay, fine, the dragons. She has not let it go. She should not let it go.
Since then I’ve read basically everything that gets shelved next to it, some of it chasing that feeling, a decent chunk out of spite. And look, most “books like Fourth Wing” lists are written by people who read jacket copy. They’ll hand you a cozy fae romance with no dragons, no academy, no casualties, and call it a comp because both covers are purple. Meanwhile the actual closest matches sit unrecommended because nobody bought them a marketing campaign. So this is the list I wanted that August: tiered, specific, and honest about which famous ones are mid. That last part is how you’ll know I mean the rest.
What dragon-rider romantasy actually is (and why it eats your sleep)
Strip away the discourse and the recipe is simple. Take the chassis of military fantasy: a war college, a chain of command, a casualty list that grows every chapter. Bolt on the drivetrain of a romance novel: forced proximity, enemies to lovers, banter as foreplay, gratification delayed until you’re feral. Neither half is new. The fusion is the thing. The academy setting makes every emotion load-bearing, because the person you’re falling for might be ordered to kill you, or might simply watch you fall off a dragon and shrug.
And the dragon matters more than anyone admits. The bond is a fantasy of being chosen by a judge who is ancient, telepathic, and immune to charm. You cannot network your way into a dragon. Violet Sorrengail spends the first book being underestimated by everyone with eyes, and then two dragons pick her anyway. That’s the drug. Not the shadow powers, not the tent scene. Being seen accurately by something that cannot be fooled.
What it feels like to read: you take the battle chapters at a sprint and the quiet chapters twice. You develop real opinions about a fictional military’s promotion structure. Dread and banter arrive in alternating waves and somehow that’s soothing. One more honest thing, since we’re here — prose is not the point of this genre. Propulsion is the point. Some books below are beautifully written and some read like a text from your funniest friend at 2 a.m., and I have tiered them accordingly.
The ones that earn the hype
The Serpent and the Wings of Night by Carissa Broadbent
The closest thing to Fourth Wing’s exact cocktail, and in a couple of ways the stronger drink. Oraya is a human raised by the vampire king as his weapon, and she enters the Kejari, a goddess-sponsored tournament that is basically Basgiath compressed into a bracket, hoping to win enough power to survive her own adoptive species. Her alliance with Raihn is enemies-to-lovers where the enemies part has actual teeth, because he’s competition and every round has a body count. What sold me is that Broadbent lets the ending cost something. No spoilers, but she makes a choice most romantasy authors are too scared to make, and the book is permanently better for it. If you take one book off this list, take this one.
Red Rising by Pierce Brown
Not a romance, and I need you to trust me anyway. If your favorite part of Fourth Wing was the institutional cruelty, the quadrant politics, the sense that the school itself wants you dead, this is that dialed to eleven with the safety removed. Darrow is a miner from the lowest caste of a color-coded society, surgically rebuilt to infiltrate the ruling class through their Institute, where the entrance exam is a war. I started it on a Sunday afternoon fully intending to nap. I read the last hundred pages standing up in my kitchen because sitting felt insufficiently urgent. Romance content: trace amounts. Rage content: off the charts.
The Will of the Many by James Islington
An academy book where the intrigue is, and I say this with affection for Basgiath, actually intelligent. Vis is an orphan with a lethal secret, enrolled in an elite academy at the heart of a Roman-flavored republic where people cede their willpower up a pyramid to the class above them. A magic system that doubles as a political argument, which is my favorite kind. Almost no romance, enormous competence, buried identities, and an ending that swings so big I put the book down and stared at a wall for a while. Give this one to the person in your life who claims they’re above dragon books. It’ll humble them.
Divine Rivals by Rebecca Ross
The gentle cousin. Two rival journalists in a city at war with a god, connected by enchanted typewriters, writing each other letters that land somewhere neither of them expects. If Fourth Wing runs on adrenaline, Divine Rivals runs on yearning, and Ross writes yearning the way other authors write sword fights. Iris and Roman’s rivalry is more newsroom than knife fight, so recalibrate what “enemies” means going in. Honest note: the sequel is noticeably weaker and the duology lands softer than it should. Read this one anyway, ideally on a rainy day, ideally a little sad.
The Bridge Kingdom by Danielle L. Jensen
An assassin princess is married off to the enemy king she has trained her entire life to destroy, and the destroying gets complicated. This is the competence pick: Lara is genuinely dangerous, Aren is genuinely decent, and the central deception has real weight because Jensen commits to the fallout instead of dissolving it with one good conversation. The kingdom itself, a chain of islands ruled from a great bridge that controls all trade through storm-wrecked waters, is the best setting-as-character on this list. Spicier than Fourth Wing. Faster, too.
Throne of Glass by Sarah J. Maas
Here’s the thing about Throne of Glass: book one reads like a CW pilot. Assassin competes in a tournament, wears pretty dresses, juggles two love interests, fine, whatever. Everyone who tells you to push through to Heir of Fire is telling the truth, because somewhere in there the series stops being a YA competition novel and becomes an enormous war epic with one of the great long-game character arcs in commercial fantasy. If what you loved about Violet is watching an underestimated woman become the thing armies get briefed about, this is the eight-book version. It’s a commitment. It mostly pays.
Deep cuts the algorithm won’t hand you
Fireborne by Rosaria Munda
The best dragon-rider book that nobody bought, and it makes me a little crazy. I found my copy on a library sale cart for two dollars, cover that looks like a placeholder, and it ate my whole weekend. The setup: a revolution has toppled the dragonlords, and the new regime assigns dragons by aptitude test instead of bloodline. Annie is an orphan the old regime made. Lee is the old regime’s secretly surviving son. They’re best friends competing for Firstrider, and the book calmly walks them toward the question of what each would burn to protect what they’ve built. It’s Plato’s Republic with dragonfire, published YA and smarter than most adult fantasy. The tournament scenes go round for round with anything in Fourth Wing. Buy it used, buy it new, I genuinely don’t care. Just buy it.
To Shape a Dragon’s Breath by Moniquill Blackgoose
A dragon academy story where the academy is the antagonist, and not in the fun push-ups way. Anequs is an Indigenous girl whose people had their own relationship with dragons long before the colonizers showed up with accreditation requirements; when a dragon hatches for her, she’s forced into the Anglish academy to be certified, where the danger isn’t a parapet, it’s policy. Slower and angrier than anything else here, with the most original dragon lore on the list. No steam, minimal romance, maximum teeth. It picked up serious award attention and roughly none of the TikTok attention, which tells you exactly what gets marketed and why.
Daughter of No Worlds by Carissa Broadbent
Broadbent twice on one list, and I’d do it again. This is her earlier, quieter, better-written work: Tisaanah, an escaped slave, essentially bullies a reclusive war mage into training her, and what follows is the slowest, achiest mentor-student burn I’ve read in this genre. If the training scenes were secretly your favorite part of Fourth Wing, the ones where trust gets built one bruise at a time, this is that as the entire engine. Less velocity, more feeling. I underlined things. I don’t underline things.
Dragonflight by Anne McCaffrey
The source code. Published in 1968, and the telepathic dragon bond you love, the hatching-ground choosing, the rider who feels everything the dragon feels, McCaffrey built all of it first. I read my mother’s mass-market copy at fourteen, spine cracked white, and the impression scene has stayed with me for decades. Fair warning: the gender politics are fully of their era and F’lar qualifies as a love interest by 1968 rules only. Read it as archaeology. Stay for Lessa, who is ninety pounds of pure spite, and for Ramoth. Always for Ramoth.
His Majesty’s Dragon by Naomi Novik
The Napoleonic Wars, except both sides field an aerial corps. A naval captain accidentally bonds a rare dragonet and loses his entire respectable life to it, and the book becomes the best platonic love story in fantasy. Temeraire, the dragon, is the finest character on this entire list, human or otherwise: curious, principled, increasingly radicalized about dragon rights. There is no romance. You will not care. If Tairn’s dialogue was quietly your favorite thing about Fourth Wing, here are nine books of that with better manners.
Blood Over Bright Haven by M.L. Wang
Not a romance, and that’s a warning label, not an apology. Sciona claws her way into being the first woman admitted to her city’s magical elite, then finds out what actually powers the utopia. It’s a standalone, it’s furious, and it does in one volume what some series can’t manage in seven. I’m putting it here for everyone whose favorite Fourth Wing ingredient was the rot inside the institution, because no book on this list itemizes the rot like this one does. Clear your evening. You won’t be doing anything else with it.
Proceed with caution: the divisive, the mid, the endless
These get recommended in every comment section on earth, and you deserve the fine print.
A Court of Thorns and Roses by Sarah J. Maas
I’m going to say it plainly: book one is a slog. It’s Beauty and the Beast with a love interest the text hasn’t yet realized is a problem, and the plot wanders around a manor for three hundred pages while you wait for something to bite. Then A Court of Mist and Fury performs the most famous bait-and-switch in modern romantasy, either a brilliant retcon or elegant gaslighting depending on which day you ask me, and becomes one of the genre’s genuinely great books. No dragons. No academy. It shows up on every “like Fourth Wing” list because money, not because it’s a real comp. Read it if you want the romance arc everybody references at you. Just know you’re eating vegetables first.
From Blood and Ash by Jennifer L. Armentrout
The twist genuinely works. The prose repeats itself like a nervous witness, and Poppy’s inner monologue circles the same three thoughts in shifts. Fans of this series are devoted in a way I find honestly touching, and I get it: the books commit to their id completely, no hedging, no shame. I skimmed the middle of every installment and still had a decent time. Between-courses reading, not the main event.
Zodiac Academy by Caroline Peckham and Susanne Valenti
Time to question my own taste in public. This series is not good. The bullying romance stays genuinely mean for entire books at a stretch, the cliffhangers are a hostage situation, the volumes multiply and thicken like something out of a horror movie. I have read four of them. So what exactly does that make me? Crack, not craft. Some of you will bounce off in twenty pages and some of you will look up in three weeks having burned actual vacation days, and I cannot tell you in advance which one you are. I could not have told you which one I was.
The Hurricane Wars by Thea Guanzon
The marketing said enemies-to-lovers like it was a legal guarantee, and that’s my whole problem. The enmity evaporates by the midpoint into an arranged-marriage simmer, which is a different trope wearing the popular one’s jacket, and I’m tired of publishers doing this. Guanzon can write, the Southeast Asian-inspired storm world is legitimately fresh, and the story’s origins as Reylo fanfic are load-bearing in ways you can feel in the pacing. Divisive for a reason. Read it for the setting, not for the promise on the sticker.
Powerless by Lauren Roberts
The Hunger Games and Red Queen run through a photocopier that sharpens nothing. It is wildly beloved by readers who haven’t met its source material yet, and maybe that’s fine; everyone deserves a first tournament book. But if you’ve been reading this genre longer than two years, you’ll see every seam. Mid, confidently.
I don’t need the love interest to be a good man. I need the author to know he isn’t.
Where to start
If you want the whole Fourth Wing cocktail, tournament and bond and romance with fangs: The Serpent and the Wings of Night.
If the brutal academy was your favorite ingredient and kissing is optional: Red Rising, or The Will of the Many if you want it cerebral.
If you want actual dragons doing actual dragon things: Fireborne first, then To Shape a Dragon’s Breath.
If the slow-burn training scenes rewired something in you: Daughter of No Worlds.
If Onyx Storm left you emotionally concussed and you need something tender: Divine Rivals.
If you want to see where the dragon bond actually came from: Dragonflight, historical seatbelt fastened.
And if you just want the famous one everybody keeps arguing about, fine, ACOTAR, but you’re allowed to skim the manor tour. If none of these land, give it six months. This genre publishes faster than any of us can honestly keep up with, and I’ll be at some airport bookstore again, losing another argument with myself.
Keep reading
I wrote a full, spoiler-marked review of Iron Flame if you want to argue with me about second-book pacing. If enemies-to-lovers is the ingredient you’re actually chasing, my roundup of enemies-to-lovers fantasy that keeps the enemies part goes well beyond dragons. And if you’re brand new to all of this, the romantasy starter guide will cost you a month of sleep. You’re welcome in advance.