A freshly dog-eared review
An Enchantment of Ravens Review: Lovely Prose, Thin Plot
Reviewers keep reaching for A Court of Thorns and Roses when they talk about An Enchantment of Ravens, because of the painter heroine and the fae prince, and that comparison sets the wrong expectation. This is a short, light, fast fairy tale with lovely sentences and a plot that cannot carry much weight. Judged as a fairy tale, it is charming. Judged as a fae romance with a full court and a long burn, it will feel thin. I’m going to judge it as what it is and tell you where it wobbles.
| Author | Margaret Rogerson |
| Published | 2017 (Margaret K. McElderry Books, September 26, 2017) |
| Genre | YA Fantasy / Fae Romance |
| Format | Standalone novel |
| Reception | Goodreads 3.64 from about 112,000 ratings (read 2026-10-30), well under the author’s later books. Publishers Weekly gave it a starred review and readers praise the prose and heroine. The split is over a romance that moves in about a week and a plot that thins out on the road. |
| Our rating | 3.5/5 |
| Content notes | Kidnapping, fighting and death, intense magical menace; a quick forbidden romance that stops short of sex |
| Read it if | you want a short, witty, lyrical fae story and care more about voice than worldbuilding |
| Skip it if | you want a slow-burn romance or a politically dense fae court |
A portrait painter, an autumn prince, and a sorrow she should not have painted
Here is the setup as reviewers give it. Isobel is seventeen and lives in the village of Whimsy with her aunt and twin sisters. She makes her living painting portraits for the fair folk, who cannot create things themselves and prize human craft the way people prize jewels. In return her family gets protective enchantments. Then the autumn prince, Rook, sits for her, and she paints sorrow into his eyes. For a fae that is a humiliating display of human feeling, and it can be a deadly one.
Rook takes her away to stand trial. On the way something attacks them, and they have to rely on each other even though the law forbids love between a human and one of the fair folk. Kirkus sums up the ride as a wild hunt, a ball, magic battles and what it called “extreme painting.” That last phrase is the book in miniature: a bit silly, quite sincere, and committed to the idea that art has teeth.
The prose and the heroine are the reasons to read it
The writing is the most consistent praise. Reviewers call it skillful, succinct and at times lyrical, and the book runs short enough that it never overstays its welcome. Isobel is the second draw. Several readers describe her as capable and observant, confident in her craft and responsible for her family, yet realistically flawed. She does not wait to be rescued, and the grounded details of her working life give her more texture than a typical YA lead gets.
Rook avoids the stoic, all-powerful love-interest mold. He is arrogant and charming, sometimes reckless, and sometimes in need of rescuing, and one reviewer enjoyed that Isobel calls him out. Another praised the court’s dark undercurrent of madness and loneliness beneath the glitter. Publishers Weekly gave the book a starred review and called it a moody debut suffused with palpable romantic longing and praised its interpretation of classic fairy themes and lore. I find that trade enthusiasm believable. The book has a clear sense of tone, and tone is half the battle in fairy-tale fantasy.
Where it splits: a romance that moves in a week and a plot that dissolves on the road
Readers settled at 3.64, and the reasons are specific. The romance is the most frequent complaint. One reviewer found a relationship that develops over roughly a week hard to believe, younger readers on Common Sense Media called it clichéd and shallow, and a few others said it felt underdeveloped or insta-love. One reader accepted it as part of the fairy-tale style. I land with the skeptics. If two characters share a danger, a law against loving each other and some very good banter, I will give them a day or two. A week is a stretch.
The plot and world are the second weak spot. A Literary Escape found the plot underdeveloped, with the reason the lands are rotting never clearly explained and the threads about the other courts loosely tied. Most of the story is a journey through the woods, with only a brief look at one court, so the worldbuilding stays thin. A younger reader noted that many threads are left unresolved, and a 1-star reader on YA Books Central found it boring. That is a fair range of complaints, and the thin worldbuilding is the one that bothers me most.
Still, I understand why people forgive it. A fast, funny, well-written fairy tale with a good heroine and a likable prince is easy to forgive. 3.5 from me: the prose earns a half star more than the plot deserves, and the romance takes one back.
A fairy tale does not owe you a map, but it does owe you a reason for the thorns.
About Margaret Rogerson
Margaret Rogerson is a New York Times bestselling author of young adult fantasy. An Enchantment of Ravens was her first novel, published in 2017, and she followed it with Sorcery of Thorns and Vespertine. She earned an undergraduate degree in cultural anthropology from Miami University and lives near Cincinnati, Ohio.
If this worked for you, read these next
- The Cruel Prince by Holly Black, for a nastier fae court and a mortal heroine who fights back
- Sorcery of Thorns by Margaret Rogerson, her next book, which Goodreads readers rate higher (4.03)
- A Court of Thorns and Roses by Sarah J. Maas, the book everyone compares this one to, if you want the longer, steamier version
For your book club
- Isobel paints sorrow into Rook’s eyes and it nearly gets her killed. What does the book say about the danger of seeing someone too clearly?
- Did the romance move too fast for you, or does a fairy-tale frame excuse the speed?
- The fair folk cannot create, so they steal human craft. Is that a convincing way to build a fae society, and does the book use it fully?
If you want your own copy to argue with me about, here’s An Enchantment of Ravens on Amazon.
More fae with sharper edges
If the fae are your weakness, start with our guide to fae court fantasies in the vein of The Cruel Prince and our list of fae romances that earn the ACOTAR comparison. Then see which ACOTAR quality you miss most, try the dark fae romance audiobooks, and browse all our book reviews.