currently overthinking our TBR

A freshly dog-eared review

The Beach-Read Action Hero Who Refuses to Age

By Paige Sutton

I bought my first Dirk Pitt novel at an airport because my actual book had gotten water damage in a hotel sink incident I still won’t fully explain, and I have never forgiven Clive Cussler for how much fun I had for the next six hours. This is not a good book in any way my MFA friends would respect. It is also one of the most purely enjoyable reading experiences I’ve had on a plane, and I’ve read a lot of books on planes.

Author Clive Cussler
Published 1976 (Pacific Vortex! was written earlier but published later; the series proper kicks off with 1973’s The Mediterranean Caper, though Raise the Titanic! in 1976 is the one that made him famous)
Genre Adventure thriller / techno-thriller
Format Series, 20+ core Dirk Pitt novels plus spinoffs (NUMA Files, Oregon Files, Isaac Bell) written or co-written by Cussler
Reception Massive bestseller status for decades, dismissed by literary critics as pulp, beloved by readers who want a submarine and an explosion and don’t especially care about prose
Our rating 3.7/5
Read it if you want a shameless, high-octane adventure with zero pretension and don’t mind cardboard characters
Skip it if you need your action heroes to feel like real people, or you’re allergic to 1970s gender politics

A Man, a Shipwreck, and Entirely Too Many Chest Muscles

Dirk Pitt is a marine engineer for a fictional government agency called NUMA, which stands for National Underwater and Marine Agency, which is Cussler’s not-especially-subtle wish-fulfillment stand-in for the real NOAA. Pitt spends his days raising sunken ships, diving on wrecks, and stumbling into international conspiracies that always somehow involve Nazi gold, a lost civilization, or a supervillain with a private island. He also, without fail, ends up with a woman falling into his arms by chapter three.

The plots are gloriously overstuffed. In Raise the Titanic!, the book that put Cussler on the map, the entire US government wants to raise the actual Titanic from the ocean floor because it’s supposedly carrying a rare mineral needed for a missile defense system. That sentence alone tells you everything about the tone of this series: earnest, absurd, and completely unbothered by its own absurdity. Pitt doesn’t just solve mysteries, he solves them while also fixing century-old ship engineering problems, seducing someone’s wife, and outrunning at least one explosion he probably didn’t need to be that close to.

I want to be clear that I am describing the plot with real affection. It’s a machine built for one purpose, forward momentum, and it does that one thing extremely well.

The Fun Is Real, the Depth Is Not, and I Have Made Peace With That

Here’s the thing. Cussler was not a great prose stylist. His dialogue is often stiff, his female characters are frequently reduced to either a damsel or a seductress (sometimes both in the same book), and his research dumps, and there are a lot of research dumps, read like Cussler fell in love with a Wikipedia article about ballast tanks and refused to cut a single paragraph of it. Sahara, one of the more famous entries, spends what feels like forty pages explaining Civil War ironclad ship design before anything happens. I have physically put the book down mid-lecture to make a sandwich.

But then something blows up, or a plane goes down in the desert, or Pitt does something so recklessly cool (there’s a scene in Iceberg where he essentially free-dives an underwater ice cave that still lives in my head rent-free) and I remember why I keep coming back. Cussler wrote pace like nobody’s business. Chapters are short. Cliffhangers land exactly when they should. You can read one of these in a weekend without ever feeling like you’re working for it, and there’s something to be said for a writer who understood entertainment as a craft, even if he never quite mastered character.

I’ll admit I question my own taste here. If I handed Raise the Titanic! to someone who reads literary fiction, they’d probably put it down by page 40 and never mention it again, and honestly, they wouldn’t be wrong to. The prose creaks. The women exist mostly to be rescued or to sleep with Pitt. The villains monologue. But I read these books the way some people watch disaster movies, not for insight into the human condition, but because I want to feel the floor tilt.

The real low point of the series, for me, is Pacific Vortex!, Cussler’s earliest Pitt novel, which he wisely sat on for years before letting it see daylight. It’s thin, it’s rushed, and it reads like a first draft that never got a second pass. If you’re going to start this series, do not start there. Start with Raise the Titanic! or The Mediterranean Caper.

Dirk Pitt isn’t a character so much as a delivery system for adventure, and once you accept that, the whole series gets a lot more fun.

About Clive Cussler

Cussler was, improbably, a real-life shipwreck hunter before he became famous for writing about a fictional one. He founded an actual organization, NUMA (the real one, no relation to the government), that located dozens of historically significant wrecks, including the Confederate submarine Hunley. He came to novel writing relatively late, after a career in advertising, and once said he wrote the kind of books he wanted to read and couldn’t find on the shelf. He died in 2020, having built one of the most durable adventure-fiction brands in publishing, co-writing dozens of later books with other authors once the demand outpaced what one man could type.

If You Want More Reckless Adventure Machismo, Try These Next

  • The Bourne Identity by Robert Ludlum, for the same propulsive plotting with slightly sharper prose
  • Jurassic Park by Michael Crichton, if you want the same research-heavy technothriller energy but tighter and scarier
  • Storm Front by John Sandford or the early Jack Ryan novels by Tom Clancy, for more of that government-conspiracy-meets-adventure-hero formula
  • Treasure Island by Robert Louis Stevenson, because Pitt is, at heart, just a modern update on the same swashbuckling impulse

You can grab the series in bulk here: Dirk Pitt novels on Amazon.

For your book club

  1. Does Dirk Pitt work as a character, or is he purely a vehicle for plot? Does that distinction even matter in this genre?
  2. Cussler’s research-heavy passages slow the pace considerably. Do they add credibility to the wilder plot elements, or just pad the book?
  3. How do the female characters in these books hold up, and does the series improve or worsen on this front as it goes on?
  4. What is it about shipwrecks and lost treasure specifically that makes for such durable thriller material?
  5. If you were adapting one Dirk Pitt novel into a movie today, which one would you choose and why has Hollywood mostly failed to make this franchise work on screen?

Want more books that know exactly what they are?

Check out more of our book reviews for the next thing to read on a plane, at the beach, or anywhere you want your brain to stop working quite so hard.