A freshly dog-eared review
Lights Out Review: Navessa Allen’s Masked Stalker Romance
The trope list on the Goodreads page for Lights Out includes “Black cat x golden retriever,” and it is the most honest line in the marketing. Navessa Allen sold a viral stalker romance, and the reviews describe a funny, soft-hearted man in a mask who treats the heroine’s cat like his own child. I like that more than I expected to. I also see why a thriller reader would feel cheated, because the stalking is brief and the menace arrives late. The jokes are why it works. The mafia plot is why it wobbles.
| Author | Navessa Allen |
| Published | 2024 |
| Genre | Dark Romance / Dark Romcom / Stalker Romance |
| Format | Book 1 of 3 in the Into Darkness series (followed by Caught Up and Game On), about 420 pages |
| Reception | 4.06 on Goodreads from more than 778,000 ratings (read 2026-10-30), 4.4 on Amazon from 102,000. Fans love the banter and the cat-dad hero; critics split over how little real stalking there is and over a second half that several say changes books once the mafia storyline arrives |
| Our rating | 4/5 |
| Content notes | Stalking (first as an invited fantasy, later as a real threat), mask and knife kink, graphic sex, a killing, and violence from a darker villain. The author lists trigger warnings at the start of the book |
| Read it if | you want a funny, soft-hearted masked-stalker romance with real banter, and you can live with plot riding in the back seat of chemistry |
| Skip it if | you want a tense stalker thriller or a serial-killer plot, or a mafia subplot dropped into a romcom is a dealbreaker |
A trauma nurse, one drunken text, and a masked man who takes her up on it
Aly Cappellucci is a trauma nurse with a kink for the masked men she follows online, and she dreams about being hunted by one in particular. Josh Hammond avoids the limelight in daily life, but at night he posts masked thirst traps for millions of fans. One follower catches his eye: Aly, who comments begging him to break into her house wearing a mask. He decides to take her up on the offer.
That is the blurb, and the second half of it is where the book points: Aly and Josh live out their darkest fantasies, unaware that she has caught the attention of someone with far more sinister intentions than a little light stalking. As the stakes rise, Josh turns from predator to protector. The publisher calls it a fast-paced dark romance with a morally gray male lead.
What works: banter, a cat-dad hero, and kink that knows it is funny
The praise is consistent and specific. One blogger rated the first half five stars and says the book kept them laughing and smiling, calling out the chemistry between two adult characters, Josh’s protective streak and his cat-as-child routine. A Goodreads reader found it surprisingly funny for a stalker romance, and another credits good chemistry, great banter and an even better cat dad. The numbers back it up: 4.06 on Goodreads across more than 778,000 ratings, and 4.4 on Amazon.
My own reading of why it lands is that Allen makes the invitation explicit. The break-in is something the heroine asks for in a comment, so the fantasy comes with a safety net that darker books deliberately refuse. That is also why the hero reads as a golden retriever in a mask instead of a predator, which is the book’s entire personality and its limit.
Where readers split: barely any stalking, and a second half that changes books
The sharpest criticism is about what the marketing promised. A 3.5-star reviewer says it advertises a stalker or serial-killer romance and delivers little of either: the stalking lasts a day or two before the leads are together almost constantly, Aly says she is scared but the outcome is never in doubt, and the accidental killing has no real stakes. The verdict is that it tried to be a plot story and a smut story and did neither well.
The other complaint is structural, and it is the one I would weigh most. The blogger who gave the first half five stars gives the second half four, because the momentum drops once the mafia subplot arrives. Two Goodreads readers who rated it three stars say the same: one liked the lighter first half and lost interest when the mafia material took over, and the other felt the author had combined two books with very different plots, so the story did not feel like the same one after the midpoint. The harshest reviews add complaints about insta-love and pacing, and one reader who gave a single star did not laugh at all, so the humor is not universal either.
Those are my two weaknesses: thin menace, and a back half that fights the front half. I still give it a 4, because the first half is genuinely fun, the humor does real work against heavy material, and the 4.06 average feels fair for the audience it was built for. If you want fear, you will be bored. If you want to grin at a man in a mask, you will be fine until about the halfway point.
A mask can promise danger for exactly as long as the man behind it stays unreadable.
About Navessa Allen
Navessa Allen is the #1 New York Times bestselling author of the Into Darkness series, according to her publisher’s author page. She lives on a farm in northern New England with her husband, several cats and a variety of farm animals. Her other titles include Scandal, Snowed In, The Lunatics and The Kings of Kearny.
If this worked for you, read these next
- Caught Up by Navessa Allen, for the next book in the Into Darkness series
- Haunting Adeline by H.D. Carlton, for a much harder-edged stalker romance (one Goodreads reviewer calls Lights Out the milder version)
- Butcher & Blackbird by Brynne Weaver, for another viral dark romcom, this one about two killers who hunt other serial killers
For your book club
- Aly starts everything with a comment asking to be hunted. Does that invitation make the stalking fantasy safer, or does it let the book skip the harder questions?
- Several readers feel the story changes at the halfway mark. Where did you notice the shift, and did it help or hurt?
- Humor is the book’s main defense against its dark material. Did the jokes make the content easier to take, or did they drain the tension?
If you want your own copy to argue with me about, here’s Lights Out on Amazon.
Dark romance without the contest
If Lights Out landed, start with our best dark romance picks, then read why dark romance is not a contest to find the worst man. For the harder edge try books like Haunting Adeline, or see what dark romance audiobooks need beyond a deep voice, and browse all of our book reviews.