currently overthinking our TBR

A freshly dog-eared review

Ninth House Review: Dark Academia With a Slow Start

By Paige Sutton

If you walk into Ninth House expecting the Grishaverse with a library card, you are in for a shock, and that includes me. This is Leigh Bardugo’s first adult novel, and it opens like a threat: a girl who survived a massacre, a full ride to Yale she has no reason to think she earned, and a job watching rich kids do ritual magic on the side. It is cold, mean and clever, and it takes a long time to get moving. I resented the slow start. I also kept reading, and by the end I could not pretend I wasn’t hooked.

Author Leigh Bardugo
Published 2019 (Flatiron Books)
Genre Dark Academia / Dark Fantasy / Mystery
Format Book 1 of the Alex Stern series (Goodreads calls it the Ninth House trilogy); sequel is Hell Bent (2023)
Reception 4.00 on Goodreads from about 433,000 ratings (read 2026-10-30), and a Goodreads Choice winner for fantasy. Readers split on the slow first 100 to 200 pages, how cold the book feels, a rushed reveal, and whether the violence earns its place.
Our rating 3.5/5
Content notes Graphic violence, drug use, and sexual assault and trauma on the page. This is not a YA read.
Read it if you want old-money rot, real magic and a murder mystery, and you can wait out a slow first act
Skip it if you need a fast opening, warmth, or a gentler follow-up to Bardugo’s young adult fantasy

A massacre survivor is sent to Yale to watch the secret societies

Here is the premise as the publisher gives it, with nothing past the first act. Galaxy “Alex” Stern grew up in the Los Angeles hinterlands with a hippie mother, dropped out early, and fell into bad boyfriends, dead-end jobs and worse. By twenty she is the sole survivor of a horrific, unsolved multiple homicide. At her hospital bed she is offered a full ride to one of the most elite universities in the world. Nobody will tell her why it is her.

The job comes with the scholarship. Yale’s eight windowless society tombs are full of future politicians and financiers, and their rituals are real and dangerous magic. Lethe House, the ninth, exists to watch the other eight, and Alex is its newest watcher. Bardugo drew on her own time at Yale for the setting. The chapters alternate between Alex in the present and her mentor Darlington slightly earlier, each headed with a season, and the two threads eventually meet.

When it clicks, it is a nasty, glamorous book about who gets away with things

The best idea here is the cynicism. The societies are not secret because they are mysterious, they are secret because they are entitled, and the magic is one more thing the privileged take because nobody stops them. Kirkus praised the tension of the drug deals, cover-ups and murder and called it compulsively readable, and it noted that Alex’s self-doubt will ring true to anyone who has spent time around elite college students. I agree with that last part. She is at her best when she is out of place and knows it. The Nerd Daily also praised the magic system as detailed enough to reward close attention, and I would add that it earns its keep: real rules make the societies’ abuses concrete instead of hand-waved.

There is dark humor, too. A reviewer at Grimdark Magazine enjoyed the jokes about celebrity alumni and a society that rigged a presidential election, and the jokes matter: they keep the book from taking its own gloom as seriously as its characters do. Readers also write most warmly about Darlington, and I see why, even if he works better as a mystery than as a person. Stephen King called it the best fantasy novel he had read in years.

Where it loses people: a slow first stretch and violence some find excessive

Here is where readers split, and I sit closer to the skeptics than the 4.00 average suggests. The opening is the main complaint. Many Goodreads reviewers call the first hundred or two hundred pages a chore, and Grimdark’s reviewer warned that the early chapters deliver a lot of information quickly, which is hard going without a feel for New Haven or classical history. One reader who gave up found the book cold and aloof, another felt not much happened for its length, and a third thought the reveal came too fast after all that build. I did not find the first act as thin as they did, but I felt every page of the setup.

The violence is the other fault line. This is far darker than Bardugo’s young adult work, and a reviewer at The Nerd Daily gave it high marks while warning about drug abuse, child abuse and sexual trauma. Some readers defend the harshness as a pointed look at what privilege gets away with. Others read it as shock. I share the reader who said Bardugo sometimes tries too hard for big, dramatic horror: it works more often than it doesn’t, but a few scenes feel like effects rather than consequences.

Alex herself divides people. Some find her complex, others find her passive and hard to connect with, and the split timeline can blur whose book this really is. My verdict is that it is smart, ambitious and badly paced, a novel I admired more than I enjoyed. If you are patient, the last third pays you back.

The richest people in the room are rarely the ones breaking the rules, because they get to write them, and this book knows it.

About Leigh Bardugo

Leigh Bardugo is the author of the Grishaverse novels Shadow and Bone, Six of Crows and King of Scars. Ninth House, published by Flatiron Books on October 8, 2019, was her first novel for adults, and it won the Goodreads Choice Award for fantasy that year. Its sequel, Hell Bent, followed in January 2023, and Amazon Studios announced a TV adaptation in October 2019.

If this worked for you, read these next

  • The Secret History by Donna Tartt, for the original blueprint of beautiful people doing terrible things at an elite school
  • If We Were Villains by M. L. Rio, for a tighter, more theatrical campus murder with a tragic gloss
  • Bunny by Mona Awad, for dark academia that goes strange and satirical instead of procedural
  • Hell Bent by Leigh Bardugo, for the direct sequel and more of Alex and Lethe House

For your book club

  1. Do the Yale societies read as a fantasy invention, or as a slightly exaggerated version of how real power protects itself?
  2. The book alternates between Alex and Darlington’s timelines. Did that structure build tension for you, or hold the story back?
  3. Is the violence doing a job in this novel, or is it there to shock? Where would you draw the line?

If you want your own copy to argue with me about, here’s Ninth House on Amazon.

More secret societies, fewer alibis

If Lethe House got under your skin, browse our best dark academia books, then try books like V.E. Schwab and books like A Discovery of Witches for more dark magic with history. The rest of our picks are in all of our book reviews.

What did you think?

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *