currently overthinking our TBR

A freshly dog-eared review

Pack Darling Review: Rough Start, Loyal Fans

By Paige Sutton

Nearly half the Goodreads ratings for Pack Darling: Part One are five stars, and several of the reviews I read call it hard to read. I find that pairing more interesting than either half. The blurb sells a heroine who has hidden her omega awakening for years and gets dropped into a pack of alphas who do not want her, in a reverse harem world with no shifters. Fans point at the characters and the writing. Readers who marked it down point at how she is treated. Both are describing the same book, so you should know what you are signing up for.

Author Lola Rock
Published 2021 (July 2021)
Genre Paranormal Romance / Reverse Harem / Omegaverse / Dark Romance
Format Part One of the Pack Darling duology (Goodreads also lists a third book, Redfang Royal)
Reception Goodreads 4.18 from about 22,000 ratings (read 2026-10-30), 45% of them five stars. Fans praise the characters and the writing. The split is over how roughly the heroine is treated in the first half and over a cliffhanger ending that makes Part Two non-optional; Part Two averages 4.00.
Our rating 4/5
Content notes Bullying that some reviewers call abuse; per the blurb, a reverse harem relationship (MMFMMM), cursing and MM scenes; a cliffhanger ending
Read it if you want a reverse harem where the men have to earn their way back, and you can sit through a rough first half
Skip it if bullying is a hard no, or you do not want to commit to a second book

A hidden omega, a pack that does not want her, and a human world with no shifters

The official blurb sets it up like this. The narrator has spent years hiding her omega awakening so she can be left alone, and she is counting on that for an independent life. Her plans end when the Wyvern Pack takes her in. The pack’s alphas, Atlas, Hunter, Finn and Jett, already have an omega, Orion, and they do not want another. The blurb places her at a snooty, stuck-up boarding school for budding omegas in the past, calls the world a human omegaverse without shifters, and warns about cursing and MM scenes.

Reviewers call the heroine Lilah; the blurb does not name her. Goodreads lists this as Pack Darling #1, and the blurb calls it book one in a reverse harem duology.

What works: the writing and the characters, according to the people who stayed

Goodreads has Part One at 4.18 from about 22,000 ratings, and 79% are four or five stars. Three of the fans I read single out the character development, the quality of the writing, or the pull of the story even when they dislike the bullying trope. One five-star reader calls the alphas awful and rates it five anyway, because all the vibes were there. That is the draw of this subgenre: men who have to be won over, and a heroine nobody expects to matter.

Where readers split: how hard her first half is, and what you owe a cliffhanger

Four reviewers object to how the heroine is treated. One gave a single star and called it abuse rather than bullying, one said the first 40 percent was very hard going, one found it hard to read while praising the heroine, and one dislikes the trope but kept reading. Two others have a different complaint, that the men avoid real consequences or that the characters feel one-note. Another reviewer says the bullying is not that cruel, so even the hard-to-read verdict is not unanimous.

Then there is the structure. Reviewers and the Goodreads shelves flag a cliffhanger, and one reviewer calls the ending frustrating. Part Two averages 4.00 against Part One’s 4.18, and several of its reviewers who loved the first half say the second let them down, while a few say it is better. So this is a two-book bet, and a mixed one.

I give it 4, which is where the reception puts it, with the warning that the price of entry is a rough first half and a second book.

Cruelty is easy to write; making the reader want it to cost something is the hard part.

About Lola Rock

Lola Rock’s Goodreads profile says she enjoys sweets, stories and travel, in that order, and that her books cannot decide whether to be hilarious or heart-wrenching. It lists 14 books and about 46,000 ratings. The Pack Darling series runs from Part One (2021) and Part Two (2022) to Redfang Royal (2023).

If this worked for you, read these next

  • Pack Darling: Part Two by Lola Rock, the second half, which you will want straight after if Part One works
  • Five Packs by Cate C. Wells, for a grovel that, per our review, costs the hero something
  • Phoenix Pack by Suzanne Wright, for a werewolf romance our review found funny
  • Wolf Girl by Leia Stone, for another werewolf romance from our shelf

For your book club

  1. How much of the pack’s behavior can a reader forgive because the book promises they will pay for it later?
  2. The blurb calls this book one of a duology. Does Part One feel like a complete story or an extended opening?
  3. Reverse harem puts one heroine among several men who start out hostile. Does that power dynamic work for you here, or does it need more consequences?

More packs, more revenge arcs

If the rough start is your kind of payoff, try our list of books like rejected mate romance and our picks for books like Zodiac Academy. Then browse all our book reviews.

What did you think?

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *