currently overthinking our TBR

A freshly dog-eared review

Rock Paper Scissors Review: A Twisty Marriage Thriller

By Paige Sutton

Nobody in Rock Paper Scissors is easy to like, and Alice Feeney seems to know it. A wife who complains, a screenwriter husband who cannot recognize faces or switch off his career, a snowed-in chapel in the Scottish Highlands: the setup is stock thriller furniture, and one reviewer called the book fairly average until its late twist. I think it is better than its furniture. The structure does the work, with two narrators, a stack of anniversary letters and a marriage that keeps rearranging itself while you watch.

Author Alice Feeney
Published 2021 (Flatiron Books, September 2021)
Genre Psychological Thriller / Domestic Suspense
Format Standalone novel
Reception Goodreads 3.86 from about 844,000 ratings (read 2026-10-30). Readers praise the structure and the twists. The split is over three hard-to-like leads, a small suspect pool and an ending that is clever to some and unsatisfying to others.
Our rating 3.5/5
Content notes A failing marriage, menace in an isolated setting, a missing pet
Read it if you want a fast, twisty thriller and do not need sympathetic leads
Skip it if you need to like the people you read about, or you tend to guess twists early

A raffle prize, a snowbound chapel, and a marriage already on the edge

Here is the setup as reviewers lay it out, and no further. Amelia and Adam Wright are close to their tenth anniversary, and neither is happy. Adam is a screenwriter with face blindness whose career has faded and whose temper has not. Amelia wins a weekend away, and the two of them drive with their dog, Bob, through a snowstorm to a converted chapel in the Highlands. Someone seems to be watching them from a window. Both are privately weighing whether to end things. Then Bob goes missing.

The form is the first thing worth discussing. Chapters alternate between Amelia and Adam in the first person, with letters Amelia wrote to Adam on earlier anniversaries mixed in, each tied to a traditional anniversary gift. A third voice appears too. Over everything hangs a famous, reclusive author whose work Adam once adapted. The couple even decide things with the game of the title.

The structure earns the twists, and the writers’ world has teeth

This is where the book wins its 3.86 across more than eight hundred thousand Goodreads ratings. Kirkus called it cleverly plotted and neatly tied up. A reviewer at Cemetery Dance said almost every chapter shifts how you see someone, and that Feeney keeps those shifts meaningful even after you start distrusting every detail. The anniversary letters give the marriage a history that the present-day chapters then complicate, which is a smarter use of the form than most thrillers manage.

The short chapters and the wintry, blacked-out setting keep it moving. Kirkus notes Feeney’s habit of leaving readers asking how she is tricking them, and this one follows the pattern. The writers’ world is a bonus: a screenwriter husband and a famous recluse of an author give the thriller a second register, which most domestic suspense does not bother with.

I also like the choice of the title game. When two people settle their decisions with rock, paper, scissors, it works as a neat image of a marriage that keeps score and dodges the real argument. It is a modest touch, and on paper it tells you more about the Wrights than a page of backstory would.

Where it splits: hard-to-like people, a leaning clue, and a verdict on the ending

Start with the cast. One reviewer wrote that none of the three main characters is likeable, and the wife complains a lot. A Goodreads reviewer said that usually bothers them but they found the couple compelling anyway. I fall closer to the second view, but I understand the readers who bounce off because they cannot care what happens to either of them.

The second problem is mystery math. With only a few characters in the present day, the pool of suspects stays small, and Jen Ryland found some twists predictable, with one clue too obvious. Another reviewer felt the isolated, haunted-chapel setting follows familiar conventions, and two more say the book starts slowly or drags a little in the middle before it builds. That is a fair knock. A thriller this dependent on its final turn has to work harder in the middle.

Then there is the ending, which people read very differently. Some call it explosive, and Jen Ryland called it interesting but said she saw it coming. Cemetery Dance made a related point: once the puzzle is solved, there is little reason to come back. I agree, which is why this lands at 3.5 for me. It is a very good first read and a thin second one.

A marriage is the only locked-room mystery where both suspects hold a key.

About Alice Feeney

Alice Feeney worked as a BBC journalist for about fifteen years before turning to novels. She is a New York Times and Sunday Times bestselling author whose books have been published in around forty languages. Rock Paper Scissors was her fourth novel, after Sometimes I Lie, I Know Who You Are and His & Hers, which became a Netflix series in 2026.

If this worked for you, read these next

  • The Last Mrs. Parrish by Liv Constantine, for another marriage that looks very different from the inside
  • The Girl on the Train by Paula Hawkins, if you like a narrator whose version of events you cannot fully trust
  • Before I Go to Sleep by S. J. Watson, for a lead who cannot rely on her own memory, much as Adam cannot rely on faces
  • His & Hers by Alice Feeney, the book one reviewer ranks as their favorite Feeney, if you want another dose of her twist machinery

For your book club

  1. The book alternates two narrators with Amelia’s anniversary letters. Which voice did you trust most, and did that change as you went?
  2. Is a couple who can barely stand each other more fun or more tiring to spend a whole thriller with?
  3. A famous, reclusive author hangs over the story and Adam’s screenwriting career runs through it. Does the writers’ world add to the story or pull you out of it?

If you want your own copy to argue with me about, here’s Rock Paper Scissors on Amazon.

More thrillers worth the lie

If you enjoyed being fooled, try our lists of twisty thriller audiobooks that play fair and Housemaid read-alikes sorted by the kind of lie, or ask why The Housemaid is such a strange comfort read. For another beautifully bad decision, see books like Verity, then browse all our book reviews.

What did you think?

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *