currently overthinking our TBR

A freshly dog-eared review

The Last Letter Review: Rebecca Yarros’s Tearjerker

By Paige Sutton

The Last Letter begins with a dead man’s request, and from that page on it is clear the book intends to make you cry. I resent being steered that openly, and it mostly worked on me anyway, which is its own irritation. Rebecca Yarros builds a slow, letter-driven romance between a soldier and his best friend’s sister, then keeps loading grief onto it. Some readers call the result devastating and earned. Others call it manipulation. I think it earns some of its tears and cheats for others, and I would rather tell you which before you buy.

Author Rebecca Yarros
Published 2019 (Entangled)
Genre Contemporary Romance / Military Romance
Format Standalone
Reception 4.46 on Goodreads from about 752,000 ratings (read 2026-10-30), and Kirkus listed it among its best books of 2019. Readers praise the letters, the slow burn and the emotional hit; they split on the pile-up of tragedy, a withheld-truth plot, a child-illness storyline and a divisive final stretch.
Our rating 4/5
Content notes A child’s cancer diagnosis, death and heavy grief, and military loss. Several readers wish the synopsis had warned about the child’s illness.
Read it if you want a slow-burn romance built from letters and you are willing to pay for the payoff in tears
Skip it if stories about sick children are a hard line for you, or you want a light romance with a guaranteed easy happy ending

A soldier, a dead friend’s last request, and letters signed with a call sign

Here is the setup, kept to the opening act. The official excerpt is a letter from Ryan to his best friend Beckett, the kind a soldier writes in case he doesn’t come back. It asks Beckett to leave the army and go to Telluride, because Ryan’s little sister Ella is raising twins alone after losing her grandmother, her parents and now her brother. There is also, the letter hints, something else Beckett doesn’t know that is tearing her family apart.

Kirkus fills in the rest of the first act. Beckett Gentry grew up in foster homes and is wary of attachments. Ella runs a resort in Telluride and is a single mother. Before Ryan’s death the two had already begun writing to each other, with Beckett signing only his call sign. When he arrives in Colorado, he bonds with the twins, starts falling for Ella, and does not tell her who he is. Letters open nearly every chapter, and the story is told in alternating first-person chapters.

The letters carry it, and the prose is better than the premise

The pen-pal structure is the best thing about this book. Goodreads readers single out the letters as the heart of the romance, one calling them touching, funny and real even while disliking other parts of the book, and another saying the correspondence is what makes the relationship feel believable. Kirkus praised the prose as crisp and poetic without being overwrought and said the characters are built through small details. I agree with all of that. Yarros can make a short note land harder than a long speech.

The slow burn works too. Beckett and Ella are both careful people, shaped by loss, and the book lets them move toward each other without rushing. One reader calls it the best and most moving military romance she has read, and several warn you to bring waterproof mascara. Kirkus also found the bond between Beckett and the twins sincere. If the premise grabs you, the first half is as good a letters-and-longing romance as I have seen on a bestseller shelf.

Where readers split: a pile-up of tragedy, a withheld truth, and a final stretch that divides people

The complaints are loud, and some are fair. The first is the weight. Readers who didn’t love it say the book stacks grief until it feels engineered. One reviewer called the tragedy overkill, and another said she hates being emotionally manipulated. I felt that too. When a book is this openly built to make you cry, every extra blow reads like a button being pressed.

The second is the withheld truth. Several Goodreads reviewers dislike lie-of-omission plots, and one said both leads brood over their secrets for too long. I understand the impulse, since Beckett’s silence is the engine of the middle of the book, but it also forces some conversations to be avoided for longer than seems plausible. Others found the book cheesy or melodramatic in places, and one found the hero too perfect to be believable.

The third is the child’s illness storyline, and it needs a plain warning. A reviewer with professional experience in pediatric oncology said the medical details felt wrong to her, and another reader quit early over the child’s cancer storyline and wished the synopsis had said so. Kirkus, on the other hand, thought the illness subplot well developed. That gap says something about how much it depends on what you bring.

The final stretch is the most divisive. Some readers call it devastating but earned, others call it gratuitous, and a few say they felt cheated because a book marketed as romance did not deliver the ending they wanted. I won’t spoil it. I’ll only say that I admired the nerve more than I trusted the choice. Four stars: the letters and the slow burn are excellent, and I deduct one for the heavy hand.

Some books earn your tears with a single sentence, and some earn them by counting how many sad things they can fit in a chapter.

About Rebecca Yarros

Rebecca Yarros was born in Washington, D.C., studied European history and English at Troy University, and began writing while her husband was deployed to Afghanistan. She is best known now for the Empyrean fantasy series that began with Fourth Wing in 2023, but she wrote contemporary romance and women’s fiction for years before that. The Last Letter, published by Entangled on February 26, 2019, is a standalone.

If this worked for you, read these next

  • The Things We Leave Unfinished by Rebecca Yarros, for another standalone from the same author, if you liked her contemporary side
  • It Ends With Us by Colleen Hoover, for a romance that is built to make you cry for a reason
  • Beautiful Disaster by Jamie McGuire, for a rowdier, younger romance with plenty of emotional wreckage
  • Fourth Wing by Rebecca Yarros, if you want to see the same author write dragons

For your book club

  1. Beckett keeps part of who he is from Ella to protect her. Is that kindness, or a lie of omission?
  2. Letters open nearly every chapter. How did they change the way you read the romance?
  3. Readers split on how much loss the book piles on. Did it feel earned, or manipulative?

If you want your own copy to argue with me about, here’s The Last Letter on Amazon.

More romances that go for the throat

If The Last Letter left you wrecked, try our emotional romances that actually wreck you and books like It Ends With Us for others that hurt on purpose. More are waiting in all of our book reviews.

What did you think?

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *