currently overthinking our TBR

A freshly dog-eared review

The Maddest Obsession Review: Banter, Heat and a Red Flag

By Paige Sutton

I distrust romance heroes who watch a woman’s every move and call it love, and The Maddest Obsession is built on one. I should have bailed. Instead I kept reading, because Danielle Lori gives her leads some of the sharpest insults in mafia romance and then lets them trade them for years. Christian is a special agent with an underworld reputation, Gianna is chaos in too-tight dresses, and the whole engine is two people who cannot stop picking at each other. It is repetitive, uneven and a little unhealthy. It is also very hard to put down.

Author Danielle Lori
Published 2019
Genre Dark Romance / Mafia Romance / Enemies to Lovers
Format Book 2 of the Made series, after The Sweetest Oblivion and before The Darkest Temptation
Reception 4.24 on Goodreads from about 264,000 ratings (read 2026-10-30), the highest of the first three Made books. Readers split on the hero’s possessiveness, repetition late in the book, long separations and time skips, and a rushed ending.
Our rating 4/5
Content notes Explicit sex, violence and murder, drug use, and references to domestic and child abuse. The hero is a killer and the heroine is married when the story starts.
Read it if you want an obsessive, morally gray hero, a heroine who is funnier than she looks, and a slow burn built from insults
Skip it if possessive heroes make you uncomfortable, or you need a plot-heavy crime story where the mafia side does more than set the scene

Two people who spend years hating each other and cannot stay away

Here is the setup as the official blurb gives it. Gianna fears the dark and hides it behind a sparkly disguise: dresses too tight, heels too tall, a laugh that is too loud, and a talent for mangling sayings. The act exists to hide one panic attack at a time. Nobody cracks it, until Christian Allister comes along. To most people he is a special agent upholding the law. In the New York underworld he is known as a hustler and a killer, with a nature as cold as the heart of ice in his chest.

He has followed a tidy life plan since youth and has a fondness for order and the number three. Gianna is not in the plan. She is chaos, not his type, and married. They meet one winter night, and then the book moves through the years, with the two of them trading insults about each other’s looks and intelligence while she starts to live for the game. Readers mention time skips, so expect a story that jumps rather than glides. The fear of the dark is the book’s best detail, because it gives all that loud performance something real to cover, and it is the reason the romance feels like more than a contest of insults.

The banter carries the book, and it mostly holds

The thing nearly every fan praises is the sparring, and I’m with them. Lori writes Christian as someone who delivers the cruelest line in the room with a perfectly straight face, and Gianna eats without decorum and mangles idioms right back at him. A blogger who gave it five stars called it their favorite of the series and found Christian a red flag in real life who works well in fiction. That is the most honest sentence I have read about this genre.

Gianna is the better surprise. A heroine who is all sparkle on the surface and carefully managed fear underneath could have been a costume. Instead the book lets her warmth be real, and several Goodreads readers call her one of their favorite heroines. The story runs across years, and I think the long timeline is what makes the insults feel affectionate by the end rather than just mean. The spice, by the way, is central to the appeal, and readers call it excellent.

Where readers split: an obsessive hero, a repetitive back half, and a rushed finish

The biggest divide is Christian. Plenty of readers love the possessiveness and the violence. Others read the same traits as toxic or hypocritical, and one objected to his double standards about other women. I land in between. The obsession is the point of the book and the title, so you cannot ask it to be softer, but I did tire of how often the story reaches for jealousy when it has run out of ideas.

The structure is the other soft spot. Several readers describe the book as character-driven with very little plot, and I agree: the underworld is mostly scenery, a set of rooms for the leads to be unpleasant in. One reader found it repetitive toward the end, another thought the stretches where the pair are apart felt long, and a few thought the backstories arrived too late or the ending was rushed even after so many years. Even some of its fans mention the repetition and the long stretches apart.

So my honest verdict is that this is a very good version of a specific appetite. It is better written on the sentence level than the genre usually bothers to be, funnier than its premise suggests, and baggier than it should be in the back half. If you read dark romance for chemistry, it delivers. If you read it for story, you will notice the gaps.

The best hate in fiction is the kind that keeps paying attention, and that is exactly why it is so hard to trust.

About Danielle Lori

Danielle Lori is the author of the Made series of mafia romances. It began with The Sweetest Oblivion in 2018 and continued with The Maddest Obsession in 2019 and The Darkest Temptation in 2020, with a fourth book, The Purest Addiction, listed as the last in the series. On Goodreads the first three books have between roughly 192,000 and 412,000 ratings each.

If this worked for you, read these next

  • The Sweetest Oblivion by Danielle Lori, for the first book in the Made series
  • Ruthless People by J.J. McAvoy, for a bigger, louder crime-family saga in the same appetite
  • Den of Vipers by K.A. Knight, for another dark romance that readers pass along quickly
  • The Predator by Runyx, for a mafia boss paired with a hitwoman who can hold her own

For your book club

  1. Christian’s obsession drives the romance. Where does it read as devotion, and where does it read as control?
  2. The story jumps through the years. Did the time skips deepen the relationship or slow it down?
  3. Gianna’s sparkle hides panic attacks. Did the book treat her anxiety with enough care, or use it as a convenient wound?

If you want your own copy to argue with me about, here’s The Maddest Obsession on Amazon.

More heroes you should not trust

If the Made series got its hooks in you, start with our best mafia romance picks, then try books like Twisted Love for darker takes on the same fantasy. The rest of our picks are in all of our book reviews.

What did you think?

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *