currently overthinking our TBR

A freshly dog-eared review

A Mafia Boss, a Hitwoman, and Zero Chill

By Paige Sutton

I read half of this book on my phone at 1am with the brightness turned all the way down so my partner wouldn’t wake up and ask why I was breathing weird at a paperback. That’s the review, honestly. I could stop there. But you came for words, so here are more of them.

Author RuNyx
Published 2020
Genre Dark mafia romance
Format Book 1 of the Dark Verse series (multiple books, loosely connected)
Reception Cult favorite in dark romance circles, divisive outside it. Readers either fall hard for the atmosphere or bounce off the slow burn and purple prose
Our rating 3.7/5
Read it if you want mood over plot, tension over speed, and you don’t mind a hero who talks like he’s narrating a perfume ad
Skip it if you need fast pacing, clean prose, or a hero who isn’t constantly comparing the heroine to a natural disaster

A hitwoman, a crime lord, and a house full of secrets

Here’s the setup, stripped of spoilers because I actually think the slow reveal is the one thing this book does right. Rune is a woman with a violent past and a very specific skill set, dropped into the orbit of Sinclair, a man who runs a criminal empire the way other men run quarterly reports: quietly, ruthlessly, without ever raising his voice. They are supposed to be enemies. They are, for a while. Then they are something messier.

RuNyx doesn’t rush this. If you go in expecting a mafia romance with a plot that clicks along like a heist movie, recalibrate now. This is a book about two damaged people circling each other in the dark, both convinced they’re the more dangerous one in the room, both slowly realizing the other person is the first person who’s ever looked at them and not flinched. It’s less “story” and more “vibe with a body count attached to it eventually.” I don’t say that as an insult. I say it because if you don’t know that going in, the first third will frustrate you.

What actually works, and what made me put the book down for a week

Let’s talk about what’s good first, because there’s real craft here that gets dismissed by people who write off the whole genre as trashy. RuNyx is genuinely skilled at tension. Not the will-they-won’t-they kind, the physical kind, the kind where two people are in the same room and you can feel the air get heavier. There’s a scene early on where Rune and Sinclair are essentially circling each other in a kitchen, barely touching, saying almost nothing, and it’s more charged than most books manage in a full sex scene. That’s a genuine skill and I don’t think enough people credit her for it.

Now the criticism, because I promised myself I’d actually give you one instead of just gushing. The prose gets away from itself. Constantly. Every glance is a “predatory gaze,” every silence is “heavy with unspoken things,” and there’s a point around the halfway mark where I started mentally counting how many times Sinclair’s eyes were described as doing something eyes cannot physically do. It’s a lot. If you’re someone who reads with a slightly raised eyebrow at overwrought metaphor, this book will test you. I laughed out loud once, not at a joke, at a line so dramatic it looped back around to funny. I want to be clear that I still liked the book. But I noticed.

Here’s the thing about Rune, though, and this is where the book earns real credit: she is not a passive heroine getting rescued by a rich scary man. She has her own violence, her own agency, her own reasons for everything she does, and the power dynamic between them is a genuine push and pull, not a one-way street. That matters more than the florid writing style, honestly. A lot of dark romance flattens its heroines into decoration. Rune isn’t decoration. She’s dangerous in her own right, and the book never lets you forget it.

The tangent I have to go on: I picked this up originally because a friend sent me a screenshot of one paragraph out of context and said “is this good or is this insane” and the answer, four books deep into this series later, is both. It’s both, constantly, on purpose. That’s kind of the whole appeal once you accept it.

Is the plot thin? Yeah, especially in this first book. The mafia machinations mostly exist to create obstacles for Rune and Sinclair to be near each other, not because RuNyx has some elaborate crime saga she’s dying to tell. If you came here for a tightly plotted underworld thriller with romance on the side, you picked the wrong book. If you came here to watch two people orbit each other until they collide, you’re exactly where you need to be. I can find the copy on Amazon and I did, more than once, because I kept lending my copy out and not getting it back.

The most dangerous person in the room is rarely the one holding the weapon.

About RuNyx

RuNyx writes under a single name, keeps her personal life almost entirely out of the public eye, and built a genuinely devoted readership through word of mouth and dark romance corners of the internet before traditional publishing caught up and started reprinting her backlist. She has a very specific brand: possessive anti-heroes, heroines with teeth, and prose that goes for broke every single time rather than playing it safe. You either vibe with that swing-big instinct or you don’t, but you can’t accuse her of holding back.

If this wrecked you, read these next

If Rune and Sinclair got under your skin, try these.

  • Twisted Love by Ana Huang, for a softer but still possessive anti-hero energy with cleaner pacing.
  • The rest of the Dark Verse series, because RuNyx’s plotting and restraint genuinely tighten up in later books, and book two fixes a lot of what frustrated me in book one.
  • Corrupt by Penelope Douglas, if you want the dark, obsessive, morally gray romance energy without the sometimes overheated prose.
  • Him by Sarina Bowen, only if you want a palate cleanser after all that darkness. Consider it dessert.

For your book club

  1. Did you find the slow burn earned, or did the pacing test your patience before the payoff arrived?
  2. Is Rune actually an equal to Sinclair in this dynamic, or does the book only tell us she is while showing something more traditional?
  3. Where did RuNyx’s writing style work for you, and where did it tip into unintentional comedy?
  4. What does this book suggest about why readers are drawn to dangerous, controlling love interests in fiction specifically?
  5. Would you have kept reading if a friend hadn’t recommended it, or does this book need a personal referral to land?

Want more books that argue with you the whole way through

Check out more of our book reviews for the ones that got under my skin the same way this one did.