currently overthinking our TBR

A freshly dog-eared review

There Are No Saints Review: Dark Romance or Dark Comedy?

By Paige Sutton

The author’s note on There Are No Saints warns you up front that this is a dark, steamy serial killer romance, which is a brave thing to say about a hero you are supposed to root for. Readers who loved it point to the chemistry. Readers who laughed at it call the same book absurd. I want to be fair to both, because the premise is a duel between two rival artists who are also predators, both fixated on one woman in San Francisco, and a premise like that earns every laugh it gets. Whether you are laughing with it or at it decides your rating.

Author Sophie Lark
Published 2021 (October 2021)
Genre Dark Romance / Serial Killer Romance
Format Book 1 of the Sinners Duet; the second book is There Is No Devil
Reception Goodreads 3.78 from about 124,000 ratings (read 2026-10-30); Amazon paperback 4.2 from about 33,600. Fans praise the chemistry and a hero who commits to being a villain. The split is over writing that some call wooden and bland, plotting that several readers find unintentionally funny, and a hero whose behavior some say crosses lines.
Our rating 3.5/5
Content notes A serial killer hero (the author’s note says so), obsessive pursuit, explicit sex, and stalking and consent problems that a few reviewers flag
Read it if you want a villain for a hero, a rivalry between two artists, and a book that is happy to be over the top
Skip it if you need restrained writing, or stalking and consent problems are a hard no

Two rival artists, one woman, and a warning label the author wrote herself

The official blurb goes like this. San Francisco thinks the narrator and Alastor Shaw are rival artists. In truth they are predators fighting over the same hunting ground, and both become fixated on Mara Eldritch. Shaw wants to use her as a pawn in his own game. The narrator’s interest is more personal, and he cannot decide whether to protect her or destroy her before she undoes him. Mara knows he is no saint, the blurb says, but she does not grasp how dangerous he is.

The author’s note then tells you what you are in for. Sophie Lark says she was drawn to true crime and anti-heroes, and that making a character who starts out evil redeemable was the challenge she set herself. It is the first of two books in the Sinners Duet.

What works: chemistry, a rivalry with a point, and a villain who commits

Goodreads has it at 3.78 from about 124,000 ratings, and 27% are five stars. Amazon’s paperback shows 4.2 from about 33,600. The praise I found clusters around the chemistry and a hero written without apology. Four of the Goodreads reviews I read praise the chemistry, and a few like that both leads are artists, so the romance and the art world tangle together. Three reviewers reach for the TV show You or for Dexter, and one calls the hero Joe Goldberg with money.

That is a decent shorthand for the pitch: a charming, dangerous man whose attention is both the appeal and the threat. If that is a pleasure of yours, this book is built for you.

Where it loses people: wooden prose, unintended comedy, and lines the hero crosses

The negative reviews are specific. Four reviewers call the writing wooden, bland or poor, citing dialogue and characters. Five reach for words like absurd, hilarious and unhinged, and some of them mean that kindly, which is exactly the problem for a book that wants to be dark. When readers are laughing, the menace is not landing. I would put that, more than any single scene, at the center of why the average sits at 3.78 and not higher.

Then there is conduct. Three reviewers object to the way the hero talks down to the heroine, and three flag stalking or consent problems, one of whom quit at the quarter mark. If the hero’s obsession is the appeal, the book is asking you to be comfortable with a lot, and it does not apologize for asking.

I land at 3.5. It is entertaining when it commits to being outrageous and weaker whenever it asks you to take the menace seriously. Read it for the nerve, not the restraint.

A villain you can laugh at is a villain who has stopped being a problem.

About Sophie Lark

Sophie Lark’s Goodreads profile lists 46 books across romance, crime and suspense and says she lives in Southern California with her husband and their three children. There Are No Saints opens the two-book Sinners series, and her author page dates both it and its follow-up, There Is No Devil, to 2021.

If this worked for you, read these next

  • The Predator by Runyx, for a mafia boss and a hitwoman in a dark romance about two dangerous people
  • The Sweetest Oblivion by Danielle Lori, for a mafia romance with a gentler hero
  • There Is No Devil by Sophie Lark, the second and final book of the duet
  • You by Caroline Kepnes, for the obsessive-narrator comparison reviewers keep reaching for

For your book club

  1. The author’s note says making an evil character redeemable was the challenge. Did the book meet it, or did it just stop asking?
  2. Where is your line between a dangerous dark romance hero and one who is simply abusive, and did this book stay on the right side of it?
  3. Does the rivalry between the two artists add tension, or does it pull focus from the romance?

If you want your own copy to argue with me about, here’s There Are No Saints on Amazon.

Darker, and not a contest

If this one scratched an itch, try our list of books like Twisted Love that take the fantasy somewhere darker and the case that dark romance is not a contest to find the worst man. Then see all our book reviews for what to read next.

Related: Dark Romance vs Dark Romantasy, Romantasy Without Fae or Vampires.

What did you think?

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *