currently overthinking our TBR

A freshly dog-eared review

Throne of Glass Review: The Uneven Start of a Fantasy Empire

By Paige Sutton

<a href="https://imlovingbooks.com/review-throne-of-glass-sarah-j-maas/">Throne of Glass</a> Review: The Uneven Start of a Fantasy Empire

Throne of Glass

Throne of Glass introduces the world’s most notorious assassin and then gives her a piano, a puppy, several gowns, and a baffling amount of free time. I say that with love and irritation in equal measure. Sarah J. Maas’s first Celaena Sardothien novel is young, shiny, and often ridiculous. It is also the small, stubborn beginning of a series that grows into an enormous fantasy about female power, chosen family, war, and the terrible men we excuse because they have cheekbones.

Author Sarah J. Maas
Published 2012
Genre Young adult fantasy / romantic fantasy
Format Book 1 of the Throne of Glass series
Best for Readers who like deadly heroines, palace competitions, slow-building magic, and long series payoffs
Our rating 4/5

Plot Summary

Eighteen-year-old assassin Celaena Sardothien has survived a year in the brutal salt mines of Endovier when Crown Prince Dorian offers her a route to freedom. She will enter a royal competition, defeat a field of soldiers, thieves, and killers, and serve several years as the king’s champion. Captain Chaol Westfall is assigned to train her inside the glass castle, where Celaena quickly discovers that winning may be less dangerous than attracting the king’s notice.

Competitors begin dying in gruesome ways. Strange marks appear, an ancient queen reaches across history, and the magic supposedly banished from Adarlan starts pressing through the walls. Celaena investigates while balancing her attraction to Dorian, her prickly trust in Chaol, and a friendship with Princess Nehemia of Eyllwe. The contest provides the official plot. The real story is a prisoner deciding how much of herself she can reveal in a court built by the man who destroyed her life.

The Assassin in the Ballgown

I came to Throne of Glass backward, after reading A Court of Thorns and Roses, and spent the first hundred pages waiting for the adult romantic heat to arrive. It does not. This is firmly YA, more stolen kisses and loaded glances than bedroom doors. Once I stopped asking it to be a later Maas book, Celaena’s contradictions became the fun. She can judge a gown, devour a bag of candy, and calculate how to kill the people around her without treating femininity as a weakness she must outgrow.

That was fresher in 2012 than it may look now. Fantasy heroines were often allowed competence only if they rejected beautiful things. Celaena refuses that bargain. Her vanity can be exhausting, but I would rather read a vain woman with appetite than another blank warrior who considers brushing her hair a political betrayal.

The trouble is that the assassin reputation mostly arrives through narration. Celaena tells us she is lethal. Other characters tell us she is legendary. Then Chaol supervises her training while she wanders the castle, attends parties, and repeatedly fails to spot obvious danger. The gap between the assassin on the label and the teenager on the page is huge. During a reread I kept a note in the margin every time security should have dragged her back to Endovier. The list stopped being useful because it became most of the book.

Two Men, One Kingdom, Not Enough Murder

Dorian is charming, curious, and trapped under a monstrous father. Chaol is controlled, loyal, and uneasy about wanting the woman he is supposed to guard. The triangle works best when it exposes different possible lives for Celaena. Dorian offers luxury and recognition. Chaol offers discipline and a harder kind of trust. Neither romance is fully convincing yet, but both create emotional pressure around her freedom.

Nehemia is the more important relationship. She forces Celaena to look beyond private survival and see what Adarlan’s conquest costs other people. The novel does not give Nehemia enough interior space, and some of her characterization exists mainly to prepare Celaena’s growth. Still, their friendship brings political consequence into a story that could otherwise disappear under velvet and flirting.

Celaena is most interesting when the book stops insisting that she is already a legend and lets us watch a traumatized, vain, furious girl decide what kind of weapon she wants to become.

The mystery is the weakest major element. Its culprit and supernatural mechanism are easier to identify than the characters pretend, while the competition loses momentum whenever the novel wanders toward courtship. Yet Maas can plant a promise. The Wyrdmarks, the sealed magic, the king’s conquests, and Celaena’s missing history all point toward a larger story. I once lent the book to a friend with the warning, “Book one is the cover charge.” She complained through book two and then vanished into the rest of the series for a month. That is a common reading path for a reason.

Rating: 4/5

The first novel’s Goodreads average is around 4.18, while later volumes inspire even stronger reader loyalty. My 4 is for this book, not an advance payment on its sequels. The obvious mystery, uneven pacing, and assassin whose legend outruns her actions all cost it. Celaena’s abrasive charm, her relationships with Nehemia and the two men, and the older magic pressing through the castle still make the actual volume compulsively readable. The groundwork matters because it is interesting here, even before later books build on it.

Author Bio

Sarah J. Maas is an American fantasy author whose three major series are Throne of Glass, A Court of Thorns and Roses, and Crescent City. She began writing an early version of Celaena’s story as a teenager and shared it online before the revised novel was traditionally published. Her work helped push romantic fantasy into the center of commercial publishing. Maas is especially known for long character arcs, escalating worlds, dramatic reveals, and love interests who arrive carrying power, trauma, and suspiciously good tailoring.

Discussion Questions

  1. Does Celaena’s love of luxury deepen her character, or does it clash with the life the novel says she has survived?
  2. Why does the book tell readers about Celaena’s deadly reputation more often than it demonstrates her skill?
  3. What different futures do Dorian and Chaol represent for Celaena?
  4. How does Nehemia challenge Celaena’s decision to focus on personal freedom rather than political responsibility?
  5. Which early details most clearly signal the larger magical story that the later series develops?

Buy the Book

Check the latest price for Throne of Glass on Amazon. A series box set makes sense if you already know you like Maas. If not, buy the first two separately. The jump in scope does not happen all at once.

Standout Moments

  • Dorian’s offer in Endovier gives Celaena a choice whose freedom is compromised from the first sentence.
  • Celaena’s first run with Chaol punctures her swagger and begins a relationship built through irritation rather than instant trust.
  • Her friendship with Nehemia turns language lessons and court companionship into quiet political education.
  • The hidden passages and Wyrdmarks bring older, less obedient magic into the king’s aggressively controlled castle.
  • The final competition forces Celaena to fight while her own body is being used against her.

I am also fond of the piano scenes. They do more for Celaena than another knife demonstration would. The music gives grief somewhere to go, and it lets Dorian witness a private self that is neither assassin nor court ornament.

Adaptation Note

As of 2026, no completed film or television adaptation has been released. A television project was once developed under the title Queen of Shadows, but it did not become a finished series. The books would be expensive to adapt because the world expands radically after the early palace story. Casting would also be a blood sport. Any version that treats Celaena as a grim assassin and removes her vanity, appetite, and ridiculous dresses would miss the person readers actually followed for seven books.

Stay for the Woman She Becomes

Browse more fantasy and romantasy reviews at imlovingbooks.com if you like watching dangerous women grow into their own mythology. This beginning is messy. So are most beginnings that later acquire an empire.


SEO title: Throne of Glass Review: The Uneven Start of a Fantasy Empire
Meta: An honest review of Sarah J. Maas’s Throne of Glass: a messy, addictive assassin fantasy whose swagger, romance, and magic improve across the series.
Rating: 4/5   Slug: review-throne-of-glass-sarah-j-maas