A freshly dog-eared review
Zodiac Academy Review: Cruel, Campy and Divisive
Zodiac Academy sells itself as a school for magic and delivers a school for cruelty that happens to have magic in it. That mismatch is the whole argument over this series. The people who adore it and the people who bounce off it are describing the same book: fast, campy, self-aware, and perfectly happy to be vicious to its heroines for over four hundred pages. This review covers Book 1, The Awakening, because that is where the pitch has to work. It works loudly on one kind of reader and not at all on another, and the content notes below will tell you which.
| Author | Caroline Peckham and Susanne Valenti (sisters) |
| Published | 2019 (Book 1, The Awakening, first published July 13, 2019) |
| Genre | Fae romantasy / dark academy / enemies to lovers |
| Format | Book 1 of the Zodiac Academy series (Goodreads lists ten numbered books plus novellas and companion retellings) |
| Reception | 3.82 on Goodreads from 495,985 ratings (read 2026-10-30): about 65% give it 4 or 5 stars and a quarter sit at 3. Readers split on whether the bullying is delicious drama or genuine abuse dressed up as romance, and the later books rate higher than this one. |
| Our rating | 3.5/5 |
| Content notes | Heavy bullying, emotional abuse and coercion; non-consensual elements that some readers find central and objectionable; vampires feeding without consent; a sex scene; near-constant profanity. The publisher recommends 18+. |
| Read it if | you want fast, funny, over-the-top academy drama, you love enemies to lovers pushed to the extreme, and you can take cruelty as a plot engine |
| Skip it if | bullying or abuse inside a romance is a dealbreaker, or you want polished prose and a school where the characters are kind to each other |
Two twins, four celestial heirs, and one very hostile school
Here is the premise as the blurb gives it. Twins Tory and Darcy Vega are on their own in the human world until they learn they are Fae, and heirs to the throne of Solaria. To do anything about that they have to attend Zodiac Academy, where your star sign defines your destiny. They are rare elementals who can wield all four elements, which makes them special and also makes them targets. The four celestial heirs want them gone, and the school is full of dangerous creatures who are not going to help.
One reviewer compared the tone to Gossip Girl crossed with Harry Potter, and that is fair. The students are sorted by Order, which covers vampires, werewolves, dragons and more, and into elemental houses that dislike each other on sight. The twins take turns narrating, and the reviewers who liked it single out how distinct their voices are. The cast is large, so the first chapters are busy, but the setup is easy to follow once the names stop colliding. The astrology is not decoration either: one reviewer points out that the star signs matter to the plot, not only to the school’s branding.
It hooks because it never sits still, and it knows how ridiculous it is
The pace is the strongest thing here. One reviewer found no filler chapters at all, just one confrontation handing off to the next, and I agree that the book rarely lets a scene idle. It is also funny on purpose, which matters more than people admit. A book this cruel with no humor would be unbearable. The camp gives you somewhere to put your eyes.
The world has real ideas in it too. Common Sense Media, which is no fan of the book’s romance, still called the elemental magic and the way the fae change by their order interesting. One Goodreads reader summed up the book as bad writing and immaculate vibes, which sounds like an insult and is also exactly why it sells. I would not call the prose good. I would call it extremely committed.
The twins are the other reason it works. Reviewers keep praising their resilience and the way they stand up to their tormentors, and a story about two sisters who refuse to be broken gives the cruelty a spine. Whatever else the book does, it never asks you to want the twins to lose, and that is a bigger deal in a bully romance than it sounds.
Where readers split: the bullying is the point, and the point is a lot
This is where the ratings stop agreeing. The complaints are specific. Common Sense Media says the harmful bullying romance detracts from decent worldbuilding and a fast plot. Some Goodreads readers object that the non-consensual content is central to the book instead of incidental. Others say the writing reads as immature, the world is confusing, or there is not enough actual romance for all the cruelty. Even the reviewer who gave it 3.5 stars calls the Heirs very hard to root for, because their behavior goes so far past mean.
I share the last complaint more than any other. Enemies to lovers needs me to believe the enemies stopped being enemies, and when the torment is this relentless, that is a lot of ground for a romance to make up. The twins can also feel one-note when the plot needs them to carry the jokes and the fights and the feelings all at once.
The defense you will hear is that it gets better. The numbers back it: Book 2, Ruthless Fae, averages 4.19 on Goodreads and Book 3, The Reckoning, 4.32, against 3.82 for this one. I believe the ratings. I only half accept the argument, because a series that asks you to endure its first book to enjoy its third is making you pay in advance. If the premise appeals, pay it. If the content notes made you wince, that is a real answer, and you can trust it. One reader who loved the series still warns that some of the later books run past a thousand pages and carry filler chapters, so the commitment is not small either way.
Enemies to lovers only works if I believe the enemies stopped being enemies, and that is the whole bet this series makes.
About Caroline Peckham and Susanne Valenti
Caroline Peckham was born in the United Kingdom and writes with her sister, Susanne Valenti. Their dark romance covers fantasy and contemporary settings, including high school bully and mafia stories. Peckham describes herself as a number one Wall Street Journal bestselling author, and Zodiac Academy, first published in 2019, is the series they are best known for.
If this worked for you, read these next
- Fourth Wing by Rebecca Yarros, for another brutal school where the classmates are a bigger threat than the curriculum, with dragons
- The Cruel Prince by Holly Black, for fae cruelty with a sharper heroine and sharper sentences
- The Serpent and the Wings of Night by Carissa Broadbent, if the lethal competition and vampires were your favorite part
For your book club
- Where is the line between a bully romance that is enjoyable cruelty and one that is abuse, and which side of it does this book land on for you?
- Tory and Darcy narrate in turns. Did the dual perspective make the twins feel like two people or one person split in half?
- The book rates lower than its sequels. Is a slow start a fair price for a series that gets better, or should the first book carry its own weight?
If you want your own copy to argue with me about, here’s Zodiac Academy: The Awakening on Amazon.
More romantasy, honestly tiered
If you want fae courts that earn the comparison, start with our books like ACOTAR list, or see where this fits among the best romantasy books and our books like Fourth Wing picks. The rest of our honest takes are on the reviews page.